Assessing the Effect of Poisoning Programs on the Density of Non-target Fauna: Design and Interpretation
نویسنده
چکیده
To establish whether poisoning programs affect non-target density, the null hypothesis that density does not decline on poisoned sites needs to be tested. However, where no statistically significant reduction in density is found, there is some probability that a biologically significant reduction has been overlooked. The probability that such an error has occurred (a Type 2 error) depends on the effect poisoning has on non-target density, the precision with which the reduction is assessed, and the number of poisoning operations sampled. Prospective power analysis can identify minimum sample sizes that reduce the probability of a Type 2 error to acceptable levels. Equivalence tests require a priori identification of the minimum change in non-target density that can be safely overlooked and the acceptable probability of doing so. As such, they explicitly link the statistical and biological significance of non-target poisoning assessments. We illustrate these principles using an experimental assessment of the effect rabbit poisoning has on the density of large kangaroo populations in Australia. A rule-of-thumb guide was used to estimate appropriate levels of power (0.85) and reductions in kangaroo density (r = -0.12) for the assessment, and a pilot study conducted to estimate the between-sample standard deviation for estimates of change in kangaroo density (s = 0.089). Prospective power analysis based on these estimates indicated that 6 poisoning programs would provide a robust assessment of the effect of poisoning on kangaroos. However, because the between-sample standard deviation was underestimated, a subsequent assessment based on 6 samples had insufficient power to usefully estimate the effect poisoning had on kangaroos. Retrospective power analysis indicated that at 0.85 power, reductions in kangaroo density as high as r = -2.2 may have been overlooked. Using the between-sample standard deviation from this assessment, changes in kangaroo density would have to be estimated for 17-19 poisoning programs if a subsequent experiment was to achieve a biologically as well as statistically robust result. __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
منابع مشابه
Determining the Topics and Content of CME Programs in Five Selected Subjects: Comparing the View Points of Experts and Target Group a Tehran University of Medical Sciences Experience
Introduction: One of the most appropriate methods for needs assessment is to assess learners' needs and arrange the educational programs based on their viewpoints. The aim of this study was to determine the topics and content of Continuing Medical Education (CME) programs in five selected subjects by medical education experts and target group, based on the real needs of General Practitioners (G...
متن کاملGenetic Analysis and Heterosis for Viscosity Parameters in Rice (Oryza sativa L.) through North Carolina III Mating Design
This study was conducted to evaluate the gene effects, heritability, heterosis and identification of appropriate breeding methods for improving rice viscosity parameters, during 2014-2016 at Rice Research Institute of Iran. The progeny obtained from the North Carolina III mating design with their parents were planted in a randomized complete block design with three replications. Analysis of var...
متن کاملThe Effect of Isolated vs. Combined Processing Instruction and Output-Based Instruction on the Learning of English Passives
The studies on the merits of processing instruction (PI) and output-based instruction (OI) have mostly treated the two approaches as mutually exclusive. To address the potentials of combining interpretation and production activities, this research compared the two isolated approaches of PI and OI with two combined approaches in which processing and output tasks were used in two opposite orders ...
متن کاملDistribution and biomass of macrobenthic fauna in the Chabahar Bay (North Eastern Sea of Oman)
Population density, distribution and biomass of macrobenthic fauna in Chabahar Bay were investigated from May 1995 to March 1996 on a bimonthly basis. The most abundant groups were Amphipods (21%), Polychaetes (19%), Gastropods (15.7%) and Bivalves (10.6%). Maximum (13000 individuals/m2) and minimum (4600 individuals/m2) were observed in May and July respectively. The changes in density were in...
متن کاملInduction of a bystander effect after therapeutic ultrasound exposure in human melanoma: In-vitro assay
Background: The induction of bystander effect via ionizing radiation has been well proven. However, few studies have investigated the bystander effect following non-ionizing radiation, such as ultrasound waves. Here, the bystander effect after different sonication times on human melanoma cell line (A375), is evaluated by assessing cell viability and apoptosis. Materials and Methods: The cells w...
متن کامل